Grouse moor-owning Lord Benyon appointed new DEFRA Minister

DEFRA press release (13 May 2021)

DEFRA welcomes new Minister

Lord Benyon has today been appointed as a Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for Defra. He will replace outgoing Defra minister Lord Gardiner, who will become Senior Deputy Speaker in the House of Lords.

The Environment Secretary today welcomed Lord Benyon, commenting on his passion and dedication to environmental causes.

Environment Secretary George Eustice said:

I am pleased to welcome Richard back to Defra. He brings a wealth of experience, knowledge and passion for the environment, developed during his previous experience as a Defra Minister and during his work as Chair of our review in to Highly Protected Marine Areas.

I look forward to working with him during this truly exciting time for Defra, with the Environment Bill returning to parliament, our agricultural reforms now starting to take root and the government leading the world on protecting nature and tackling climate change. Richard will be invaluable as we continue our ambitious work to ensure we leave our natural environment in a better state for future generations.

I would also like to extend my congratulations to Lord Gardiner on his election as Senior Deputy Speaker in the House of Lords and to thank him for his work as Minister in Defra.”

Defra Minister Lord Benyon said:

It’s both a privilege and a pleasure to be returning to Defra as a Minister in the House of Lords. I have fond memories from my time as Parliamentary Under Secretary of State.

From the flagship Environment Bill and tackling climate change to helping our farmers through the agricultural transition and supporting our fishing industry, Defra is at the heart of this Government’s work to build back greener. It’s an exciting time to be back at Defra.

I look forward to working with everyone as Defra tackles some of the greatest challenges of our time.”

Lord Benyon’s portfolio will be confirmed in due course.


Grouse moor and pheasant-shoot – owner Richard Benyon is a former Trustee of GWCT and is no stranger to the pages of this blog. E.g. this from 2014:

In 2013, as Wildlife Minister under David Cameron, Richard Benyon refused to make possession of Carbofuran a criminal offence in England, despite other MPs calling for such a move, and despite it being an offence in Scotland, and despite it being well known that Carbofuran is the gamekeepers’ poison of choice for killing birds of prey.

In response, Caroline Lucas MP (Green Party) said:

The minister’s shocking refusal to outlaw the possession of a poison used only by rogue gamekeepers to illegally kill birds of prey would be inexplicable were it not for his own cosy links to the shooting lobby“.

Also while Mr Benyon was in post at DEFRA, the government sanctioned the controversial buzzard ‘management’ trial and committed £375k of taxpayers money to help support it (see here), although they swiftly backtracked after a huge public outcry against the plan (see here). However, the following year Natural England, acting on behalf of DEFRA, decided to go ahead and issue a licence (to a gamekeeper with a past conviction for wildlife crime) to destroy buzzard eggs and nests to protect pheasants (see here).

Mr Benyon also decided there was no need to introduce vicarious liability to England because “there are very good laws in place to punish the illegal killing of any animal. If they are not being effectively enforced, they must be and we will take steps to make sure that happens. However, this is a good opportunity to applaud gamekeepers for the wonderful work they do in providing excellent biodiversity across our countryside” (see here and here).

In 2016 he spoke at the Westminster Hall debate on driven grouse shooting where, along with other grouse-shooting pals and supporters, he claimed that a ban on driven grouse shooting would be ‘a catastrophe for the biodiversity of the uplands‘.

It’s probably safe to assume that this latest appointment to DEFRA’s ministerial team will have significant influence on campaigning efforts to rid the English uplands of the wildlife crime and environmental damage continually associated with driven grouse shooting.

It doesn’t mean we’ll stop trying, though.

17 thoughts on “Grouse moor-owning Lord Benyon appointed new DEFRA Minister”

  1. That news has just changed my vote in the next General Election. Looking at the options my vote could go to the raving loony party.

  2. Oh shit we are where we were 15 years ago this man is on their side more than one could imagine and not in a good way.

  3. How many raptor kills in / around his moors?
    Not “poacher turned gamekeeper” but “Gamekeeper turned law-maker!”

    1. To be fair, his estate is now one of a handful of better ones in an area that was a well-known persecution hotspot. There are definitely some still at it, but I don’t believe so on his estate.

  4. In a way this might not be a bad thing. If we accept that his vested-interest group are already ensconced in the engine room of Defra and the wider government, steering the ship from behind the scenes. Then at least here we have an officer who is “one of them” visible and accountable on the bridge, seemingly inviting the close scrutiny of his decisions and of activity on his own Estate(s).

  5. That’s how Boris does business, is it not? Say one thing, do another and give an interpretation to justify his deception and then leave the topic never to return to it again. Expect more nasty surprises.

    1. Spot on George. One of your colleagues used the great phrase today “slippery as a bar of soap in a hot bath”

      However when it comes to the environment It is just as well that there are more of us than there are of them!

    1. Ruth

      I’ve just been checking my references. The links I found confirming the names and one of the meetings I mentioned no longer work. Apologies. Thanks for asking for sources! Sorry.

  6. I suspect the landed elite who own the grouse moors will be very relieved to note they now have an alley in DEFRA to ensure any changes proposed by the reforms to agriculture or the environment to tackle climate change won’t greatly upset the apple cart.
    Grouse and game shooting will no doubt continue in their current form; and public money will probably still flow to land owners to continue conservation work which ensures high game bird numbers, but doesn’t fully utilise the land to tackle climate change or the extinction crisis.
    I don’t think under this current government we will see any meaningful change to eradicate raptor persecution.
    What is really needed is a fresh pair of eyes; but this appointment will probably just help maintain the status quo, and ensure any changes to legislation do not make the actives of the rich and powerful unlawful, as they manage their lands in ways many people disagree with.
    For those interested in politics, this perhaps indicates how the political processes can be manipulated to ensure the vested interests of the rich and powerful are maintained, whilst giving the illusion that we live in a democracy.

  7. Things don’t change, do they? Shades of Nicholas Ridley stacking the old NCC Council with hunting and shooting interests back in the late 1980s.

  8. He has in the past been all for, the destruction of buzzards (even trying to get £250,000 funds from the government to study the need.), not making banned poison possession illegal, xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxx xxxxx and no doubt much more.

    I would not trust him at all.


    [Ed: Thanks Douglas but you’ll need to provide evidence to support those further accusations before they can be published here]

  9. “leading the world on protecting nature and tackling climate change.”
    “flagship Environment Bill”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s