In May 2017 Scottish Environment Cabinet Secretary Roseanna Cunningham initiated a review of grouse moor management following continued evidence of widespread illegal raptor persecution associated with this type of land use (here).
Six months later the members of the review group were announced by the Scottish Government (here) and the review process became known to many of us as the Werritty Review, named after the group’s Chair, Professor Alan Werritty.
Throughout 2018 the Werritty Review group met with a series of individuals and organisations and provided regular reports on progress (here). These reports were welcome although the content was only summarised and no real detail has emerged.
That’s fair enough – we’ll find out the detail in due course, once all the formalities have ended. We’ve been told that the Werritty Review Group’s report will be submitted to Roseanna Cunningham this spring, although in the group’s terms of reference published on the Scottish Government website (here) it states the final report will be submitted “before the end of June 2019“. Hmm, let’s hope we don’t have to wait that long.
But hang on a minute, according to the GWCT, if you’re willing to pay £30 to attend its ‘Game Scotland 2019’ conference in March you’ll get to hear all about the Werritty Review group’s preliminary results before anyone else, assuming that the ‘Grouse Moor Review Panel’ described below is the same as the Werritty Review. What other ‘Grouse Moor Review Panel’ is there?
This can’t be right, surely?
Who will be presenting those “preliminary results” to conference attendees? Will it be a member of the Werritty Review Panel? Perhaps Professor Werritty himself?
Will these preliminary results be revealed before the final report has been submitted to the Scottish Government?
How can the results of a Scottish Government-funded review, paid for with public funds and of huge national interest, be given to the GWCT before being released to the public?
We’ll be asking the Scottish Government if this is true and if so, for an explanation…..stay tuned.
UPDATE 1 Feb 2019: Secretary for Werritty Review confirms prelim results will not be presented at GWCT conference (here)
10 thoughts on “Prelim results of Prof Werritty’s grouse moor review to be revealed at GWCT conference?!”
Well spotted…I suspect they may now change their programme!
If true then I guess someone on the Review Panel may have provided information.
Should we look any further than either Mr Jameson or Mr Oddy? Or is this just my jaundiced view? Probably!
Something dosent quite smell right here ,and I don’t think it’s a stinkpit !!
What are they up to?
Almost worth the fee to be a fly on the wall and its what you would expect to pay to see a good comedy act perform.
How can it be, that GWCT has access to this document, before the committee? Will you please let us know what answer you are given, when you ask this same question? It appears someone must have leaked this and that person/group MUST be publicly identified.
GWCT has been quickly backtracking on its claim that it will have prior access to the Werritty Review Group’s recommendations. See latest blog: