Natural England has announced that a total of 19 hen harrier nests were successful in England this year.
Strangely, Natural England didn’t mention the number of hen harriers that have disappeared in suspicious circumstances this year, or those that members of the public witnessed being shot (see here).
[A dead hen harrier that was caught in an illegally-set trap on a Scottish grouse moor – see here. Nobody was prosecuted for this barbaric crime. Photo by Ruth Tingay]
With a straight face, Natural England’s Chairman Tony Juniper has declared this year’s hen harrier breeding season a ‘wonderful result’ (since when has a 5% success rate been ‘wonderful’?) and, along with his good old pals from the grouse shooting industry (the very industry responsible for this species’ appalling conservation status), has issued a joint press release as follows:
A record-breaking year for hen harrier breeding
Natural England has recorded the best year for hen harrier breeding in England since Natural England’s Hen Harrier Recovery Project was established in 2002, with 60 chicks fledged from 19 nests across Northumberland, Yorkshire Dales, Cumbria and Lancashire in early summer 2020.
The success has been down to a number of factors including high numbers of voles which are a key food source, good weather, and strong partnership working between Natural England, RSPB, Forestry Commission, the Moorland Association, United Utilities, the National Trust, and others.
Hen harriers were once found across upland and lowland Britain including throughout many English counties, however after 1830 it became an exceptionally rare breeding bird in England due to raptor persecution, which was then made illegal in 1954. The hen harrier is now one of England’s rarest birds of prey.
Hen harriers are one of our most distinctive birds, with a characteristic owl-like face and stiff facial feathers that direct sound toward their ears to enable them to hunt more effectively.
Tony Juniper, Chairman of Natural England, said:
“2020 has seen the best breeding season for England’s hen harriers in years and I thank all those who’ve helped achieve this wonderful result, including landowners and managers, campaigners, conservation groups, police officers and our own Natural England staff and volunteers.
“Despite the great progress there is though no cause for complacency. Too many birds still go missing in unexplained circumstances and I urge anyone who is still engaged in the persecution of these magnificent creatures to cease at once.
“Hen harriers remain critically endangered in England and there is a long way to go before the population returns to what it should be.”
This year’s success means that 141 hen harrier chicks have fledged over the past three years alone. Natural England’s Hen Harrier Recovery Project was established in 2002 to monitor hen harriers and work towards improving their numbers in England.
Although persecution is thought to be the main factor limiting hen harrier numbers in England, other factors including the suitability of local habitats and food availability are also significant in some areas.
Natural England is involved in a number of initiatives to help ensure hen harriers recover including through Defra’s hen harrier joint action plan.
- satellite tracking to improve understanding of the bird’s movements and behaviour;
- supporting wildlife friendly habitat management in the uplands; and,
- working with a range of partners to protect the current population and extend its range across England.
Dr Adam Smith of the Game & Wildlife Conservation Trust (GWCT), said:
“This is a very promising result for a pragmatic conservation project. Management options for bird of prey conservation rather than just legal enforcement is very forward thinking approach. The GWCT has studied the very real tension between harrier conservation and grouse shooting for over 30 years. Until this managed approach was adopted – at no small risk to the reputations of all involved – there was a damaging deadlock.
“If this trend can be maintained and hen harrier conservation status further improved, whilst supporting the red grouse management that best delivers our unique heather uplands, it will be a real breakthrough for practical, working conservation.”
Amanda Anderson, Director of the Moorland Association, added:
“Yet again, it has been a fantastic year for hen harriers and we have now seen significant increases in successful nests and chick numbers for three years running as part of the hen harrier Recovery Plan which includes the innovative Brood Management Scheme trial.
“Twelve of the nests reported today are on land managed for grouse shooting and this reflects a genuine commitment from moor owners and managers to work with others and help rebuild the harrier population.”
Hen harriers lay 4-6 eggs during late April–May, with incubation lasting 30 days. Hen harrier chicks then fledge in 28-32 days. Both females and males attend the young, with the males providing food which is often passed mid-air to the female in a distinctive display of ‘throw and catch’.
A high proportion of this year’s chicks have been fitted with satellite tags, which will allow Natural England to monitor the progress of the birds as they move away from their nest areas.
What this press statement amounts to is nothing more than a cynical ploy to disguise the tragic reality of this species’ downfall at the hands of the driven grouse shooting industry.
It’s hard to know where to start with this latest piece of deliberately crafted propaganda. Isn’t it interesting though, that the only other organisations quoted are the GWCT and the Moorland Association? Where’s the RSPB quote? The Police? Forestry Commission, United Utilities, National Trust, and the ‘others’ that were mentioned as ‘partners’ by Tony Juniper (presumably he means the Northern England Raptor Forum)? Weren’t they asked? Or were they invited to comment but refused to have any part in this conservation sham?
And then there’s the actual results – 19 successful nests in the whole of England is nothing like a ‘wonderful result’. It’s bloody pitiful – just 5% of the potential English breeding population estimate of 330 pairs. The fact it’s been the ‘best breeding season since 2002’ says an awful lot about how long and how severely this species has been a victim of illegal persecution, doesn’t it?
And then there’s Tony Juniper telling us, ‘Persecution is thought to be the main factor limiting hen harrier numbers in England…’ No, Tony, it’s not thought to be the main factor, it’s known to be the main factor and has been known for many, many years. Natural England’s own data have been used to evidence this time and time and time again! [see update 14 Sept below]
It’s hardly worth dissecting the quotes from GWCT and the Moorland Association. It could be argued that these organisations have about as much credibility on hen harrier conservation as the Kremlin has on the destruction of its stockpiles of Novichok.
It is worth noting though that back in 2002, the very same year that Natural England first implemented its so-called ‘Hen Harrier Recovery Project’, that the then Chairman of the GWCT’s Scottish Committee and later Vice Chair of the national GWCT was proposing an opt-out from the European Birds Directive to enable grouse moor owners to cull hen harriers that threatened red grouse stocks for shooting (see here). Perhaps today’s quote from the GWCT, talking about ‘management options’ for birds of prey, is a more carefully-worded version of the same principle?
It’s also worth noting that in this latest press statement, both the Moorland Association and GWCT appear to be keen that the grouse shooting industry deserves recognition for this ‘record-breaking season’. Yes, the industry does deserve recognition, but only for keeping the English hen harrier population at such a critically low level for so many years.
It’s funny, isn’t it, that the industry wants credit when hen harriers are allowed to breed on a grouse moor but it refuses to accept any responsibility for the hundreds of vacant breeding territories right across the English (and Scottish) uplands, nor responsibility for the suspicious disappearance of at least 72% of satellite-tagged hen harriers that are, according to Natural England’s own data, presumed to have been illegally killed on grouse moors.
Talking about disappearing and illegally killed hen harriers is something the Natural England press statement doesn’t do. Why not? Well, because if it admitted that at least 43 hen harriers have disappeared in suspicious circumstances (or been found illegally killed) on or close to driven grouse moors in the last two years alone (see here), then it would be blindingly obvious to anyone with an ounce of common sense that the 19 successful hen harrier nests recorded in 2020 are totally irrelevant to the conservation recovery of this species if those recently-fledged young birds are subsequently shot, poisoned or trapped on grouse moors. Which, long experience has shown, is what will happen to many of them, probably before Xmas.
UPDATE 10.30hrs: ‘Illegal persecution remains most serious threat to hen harriers’ – RSPB statement on 2020 breeding season (here)
UPDATE 19.00hrs: Four of this year’s satellite-tagged hen harriers already dead or ‘missing’ (here)
UPDATE 12 September 2020: Northern England Raptor Forum statement on 2020 hen harrier breeding season (here)
UPDATE 14 September 2020: It’s been pointed out to us that we’ve wrongly attributed the quote, “Persecution is thought to be the main factor limiting hen harrier numbers in England…” to Tony Juniper. Our mistake. It is, though, still a quote attributable to Natural England, of which Tony Juniper is Chair.
23 thoughts on “Deluded Natural England claims 2020 hen harrier breeding season a ‘wonderful result’”
To be expected, as unnatural England is, and never has been any friend to wildlife of any sort. They are in the pockets of industrial agriculture, and large estate owners.
I think we need to know exactly how many of this years Hen Harriers were satellite tagged; a high proportion is perhaps deliberately rather vague; strange RSPB is not included in the Nat. England PR when GWCT and MT are; politics of survival for Tony Juniper?
I don’t think we do need to know how many have been tagged, let’s keep the dark side in the dark, suffice to know that many have been tagged. I’m surprised Juniper didn’t choke on this guff, its still just less than 6% of what we should have and no mention of failures and there will have been some, natural and otherwise.
what really sticks in the craw is the gushing bullshit from Anderson and GWCT about co-operative working, if it were not for their members, funders and lackies we’d not be here in the first place, as the near demise of English harriers is all down to persecution. That some/ a few are no longer doing this is not to be congratulated but challenged as to why this has not always been the case for all of them. As somebody involved in Hen Harriers for nearly 40 years one cannot forgive and forget quite so easily. NE had the backbone in 2008 to say it as it was, they are now a shadow of their former selves in bed with the enemy with no shame.
Yes of course…I am just remarking something of the political reality in a Conservative Party that purged its European wing and where dissent is not tolerated. Its one hell of a nettle Juniper has grasped…not sure he has many allies.
Just for a bit of perspective on this, here in Orkney there were 59 Hen Harrier chicks recorded as close to fledging in 2018, 67 in 2017 and 73 in 2016. Guess what? We have no grouse shooting and no gamekeepers.
Hi Andy, playing devils advocate I posted your comment on the M.A. page on fb. Hope you don’t mind? Anyway, I’m afraid one of the shooters there, who claims to live on Orkney, has been poo pooing the comparison between Harriers on Orkney & the mainland. He reckons that we shouldn’t use Orkney as a statistical basis for the UK’s harrier population, as the situation up there is incomparable. He claims that there “is grouse shooting in Orkney on parts of Birsay Moor”. He goes on to say that the Harriers don’t occupy moorland on Orkney because it’s unmanaged, rank and devoid of prey & says they have no mammalian predators and very little competition from other BoP. However, when pressed he conceded that there are of course lots of other Birds of Prey up there, including Short-eared Owls, Merlins & Peregrines. His notion is that the Orkney population shouldn’t be compared to moorland based Harriers on the mainland. Never having been to Orkney myself I’m not in a strong position to debate the point with him, so wondered if you had any thoughts to add to our debate? Cheers, Dick
Ah yes, Ross McIvor strong advocate of shooting and very anti RSPB. I read the comments you’re referring to. Here is a piece of it summing up “there is grouse shooting in Orkney on parts of Birsay Moor that the RSPB haven’t ruined through passive mis-management. Shapinsay is keepered in its entirety. Once again, the Harriers don’t occupy moorland in Orkney – so you cannot co-opt their numbers into your “quotes.” I’ll answer in order; 1. There may be some grouse shot on Birsay Moors but it’s not keepered, nor driven so it will just be casual shooting. 2. As far as I’m aware, all Hen Harriers in Orkney breed on moorland. Where else would they breed? On the shore?. There is one mammalian predator now, with the advent of stoats in Orkney since 2010. McIvor also says “Short Eared Owls, Hobby, Merlin, Peregrines.. ..but again, they occupy marginal grassland where the food is – not moorland.” Hobby does not breed in Orkney. Merlin breed solely on moorland and Short-eared Owls mainly on moorland. Peregrines nest on the cliffs and a few on rocky outcrops – on the moors. Just for context, I use to manage an RSPB moorland reserve here in Orkney. Managed for Hen Harrier, Merlin and Short-eared Owl mainly.
Good to see Ruth get the last word in the Guardian article…..
We have a massive amount of suitable habitat here in North East Wales and as far as I know, no Hen Harriers. Just a hunch, but they shoot grouse on this land too??
Well done Ruth, a very comprehensive and clear critical analysis, as usual.
Perhaps we could via this blog and in the interest of balanced reporting, ask the RSPB, the Police, the Forestry Commission, United Utilities, the National Trust, and the Northern England Raptor Forum to give us their current thoughts and views?
NE last updated their hen harrier database in NOV 2019. Shows their commitment to being open and transparent doesn’t it? No mention, as yet, of last years brood meddled, and now deceased, hen harrier chicks.
I have just checked and low and behold NE have just updated their hen Harrier database today.
23 new tag entries in 2020, 4 of which are either dead or missing already. Fingers crossed for the remaining 19.
Why are there only quotes from those with a vested interest in driven grouse shooting?
There seems to be two different press releases merged into one? Ex-conservationist Tony Juniper talks vaguely about “flowers and spring”, while “killing for fun” spokes people talk about the previously un-mentioned brood meddling scheme being the cause of the “success”? How confusing. Have any of the meddled birds actually survived long enough to breed?
If the action plan started in 2002….and the killing had stopped (ie the plan worked)…what would the population level now be?
I just looked in on the Rewilding Scotland fb page and someone has actually posted the press release claiming that it’s good news from any angle. Pleased to say they’ve been given very short thrift indeed as has anyone conveniently turning up to support the original poster’s viewpoint. Clearly there are those who want to squeeze as much PR value out of this as possible. Sign o the times they have to do so much to get so little back, they were hammered on RS.
Amanda Anderson highlights the “innovative brood management scheme” as a key part of this ‘success’. This implies that the problem facing Hen Harriers is that they are unable to successfully raise their own chicks. We know that (provided there is no malicious intervention from a gamekeeper on the sly) this is not the case. I would be intrigued to know how many of the 60 chicks were actually from managed/meddled broods but there is no reason to suppose that the numbers fledged would have been substantially fewer had the nests all been left to their own devices (including by malicious GKs). Furthermore, as pointed out above, even if many more than 60 chicks had been fledged this year that would count for nothing if the majority of them end up being shot before they are ever able to breed themselves.
We can talk about success when the survival rate of fledged birds matches what could reasonably be expected in a non-persecuted population and the number of occupied territories starts to approach what might be expected from the area of suitable habitat available.
I heard on radio 2 news… I sat screaming in my truck bollox bollox bollox… People must of thought me crazy……. And they would be correct 😭😭😭👍👍👍👍
Put their words in a proper perspective and context what they are actually doing is lying to your face.
People who do that have no respect for anyone or anything other than themselves, their cabal and their own selfish goals.
Un natural England seem to be very suppportive of the wealthy shooters .
I also wonder why Friends of the Earth (England) and The Green Party (England) have NOTHING say about their former Director trying to cosy up to the shooting industry?